Complete catalog audit — September 7, 2026
Complete catalog audit — September 7, 2026
Reviewed every entry file for public/excluded status, current headline, status wording, and direct source links. This is a catalog and sourcing inventory, not independent verification of every historical claim. The three companion research reports document which cases received fresh source research.
Public entries: 115. Excluded legacy/duplicate/source-only pages: 8. A zero link count does not mean no source is named; many entries cite clippings bibliographically without an online link.
| Entry | Visibility | Status | Direct external links |
|---|---|---|---|
| Thomas R. Mulcahy and the Route 72 bags (1992) | Public | Conviction and appeals documented | 2 |
| The Ong’s Hat triple killing (1934) | Public | Unresolved triple homicide | 1 |
| The killing of Lisa Armstrong (2013) | Public | Documented homicide | 0 |
| Grace Morey shooting at Atsion | Public | Sources compared and paraphrased | 0 |
| A doubtful sighting in Jessup’s woods | Public | Contemporary source summarized | 0 |
| Bass River, 1977: the fire that trapped four volunteers | Public | Documented history · Sources compared | 11 |
| The bear behind the Somerville Inn | Public | Contemporary source summarized | 0 |
| The bear that kept Kearny indoors | Public | Contemporary source summarized | 0 |
| The mysterious Winslow-area predator | Public | Contemporary source summarized | 0 |
| Henry C. Beck on the old Tuckerton Road | Public | Paraphrased route and place digest | 0 |
| The killing of David Beebe at Chairville (1907) | Public | Documented homicide | 1 |
| Craig Bender (1940) | Public | Recovered missing child | 3 |
| “Bigfoot” or escaped cat? Berkeley Township, 1979 | Public | Sources compared and paraphrased | 0 |
| The unidentified man killed near Whiting (1904) | Public | Unidentified person | 0 |
| Unidentified man found at Stafford Forge (2013) | Public | Identity and cause of death unresolved | 3 |
| The Brazilian cardinal in the cold | Public | Contemporary source summarized | 0 |
| The Bradway Brown burglary murder (1933) | Public | Documented homicide | 0 |
| Bradway Brown shooting (1933) | Public | Paraphrased investigation digest | 0 |
| Elmer Brown, railroad brakeman | Public | Contemporary source summarized | 0 |
| Howard G. Bryan | Public | Documented account | 0 |
| Harriet Butler | Public | Documented account | 0 |
| Andrew Canzoneri (1937–38) | Public | Sources compared and paraphrased | 0 |
| Captain Emilio Carranza | Public | Documented account | 0 |
| The disappearance of Charles L. Carslake (1933) | Public | Documented death | 0 |
| Hannah Harriet Chattin and the Brooksbrae fire (1917) | Public | Documented deaths; manner disputed | 1 |
| Chestnut Neck: a port burned, a river full of evidence | Public | Documented history · Sources compared | 11 |
| Elizabeth’s tomato-throwing chimpanzee | Public | Contemporary source summarized | 0 |
| The creation of Cinnaminson Heights | Public | Contemporary source summarized | 0 |
| Cinnaminson-area property map (1876) | Public | Map identification incomplete | 0 |
| Wellington Park, Cinnaminson | Public | Paraphrased development history | 0 |
| The Clump of Woods Man (1956) | Public | Documented account | 0 |
| David Alan Cohen disappearance | Public | Unresolved disappearance | 0 |
| Packard Single Six advertisement | Public | Paraphrased advertisement note | 0 |
| The Jackson Township “Cosa Nostra cemetery” search (1967) | Public | Documented federal investigation | 0 |
| Giuseppe Domioni | Public | Documented account | 0 |
| Michael “Mikey” Dorn | Public | Documented account | 0 |
| Double Trouble: a working village behind a strange name | Public | Documented history · Sources compared | 8 |
| Dunham, Percy (1969) missing plane | Public | Unresolved aviation disappearance | 0 |
| Elizabeth Burr’s killing near Flyat (1895) | Public | Husband accused; final court outcome not located | 1 |
| The North Camden monkey search | Public | Contemporary source summarized | 0 |
| Tarzan’s three-hour chase | Public | Contemporary source summarized | 0 |
| The cave creature near Florida, New York | Public | Location corrected; claim unverified | 0 |
| Howard Freyberger (1931) | Public | Paraphrased death notice | 0 |
| Friendship, Bozarth’s Mill, and Eagle | Public | Paraphrased route and place digest | 0 |
| Minnie Fulton | Public | Documented account | 0 |
| The search for General Clinton’s treasure | Public | Contemporary source summarized | 0 |
| The ghost story of Mary Ann Forge | Public | Paraphrased folklore and site history | 2 |
| Donald Caldwell and Steven Soden (1972) | Public | Sources compared and paraphrased | 2 |
| Michael Holiny Jr. | Public | Documented account | 0 |
| Hosea Moore and Samuel Prickett | Public | Documented 1838 conviction; earlier disappearance is family tradition | 2 |
| The Hunterdon farm-damage report | Public | Contemporary source summarized | 0 |
| A. Arthur Hutchinson (1872) | Public | Sources compared and paraphrased | 0 |
| Danielle Imbo and Richard Petrone Jr. (2005) | Public | Missing persons; FBI sources updated | 3 |
| The murder of Carrie Brown (1891) | Public | Identification and legal outcome established | 1 |
| The Jericho sightings | Public | Contemporary source summarized | 0 |
| William P. Kane | Public | Documented account | 0 |
| Solomon Knopp (1872) | Public | Source-limited account | 0 |
| Robert Korman (1972) | Public | Sources compared and paraphrased | 0 |
| Sarah A. Lambert, James Ware, and John Wesley Neale | Public | Available sources summarized | 0 |
| The Middletown zoo leopard | Public | Contemporary source summarized | 0 |
| Arthur Luciani (1979) | Public | Sources compared and paraphrased | 0 |
| Dr. Dorothy Lush | Public | Two notices compared | 0 |
| Giuseppe Mercurio (1907) | Public | Homicide; Italian conviction reported | 1 |
| Woodburn “Baldy” Miller and Jean Bush | Public | Available sources summarized | 0 |
| Margaret Mitchause throat-wound inquiry (1894) | Public | Unresolved assault | 0 |
| Unidentified man found near Indian Mills (1941) | Public | Sources compared and paraphrased | 0 |
| The squirrel monkey of Atlantic Avenue | Public | Contemporary source summarized | 0 |
| Spencer Moses (1945) | Public | Paraphrased court brief | 0 |
| Gathering sphagnum moss for aircraft | Public | Contemporary source summarized | 0 |
| Peter Myers disappearance and recovery (2022) | Public | Documented missing-person case | 2 |
| Nehrwein Atsion Woman (Anna Maria Nehrwein) (1887) | Public | Unresolved death | 0 |
| Catharine “Kate” Maria Nehrwein (1887) | Excluded | Paraphrased research digest | 0 |
| New Lisbon Diabetic Missing (1954) | Public | Unresolved missing person | 0 |
| Notebook Man (1927) | Excluded | Source image unreadable | 0 |
| Joshua Ogden (1879) | Public | Sources compared and paraphrased | 0 |
| Para-Dice Club | Excluded | Research lead, not an identification | 0 |
| The Mountain View escape | Public | Contemporary source summarized | 0 |
| David F. Paul (1920) | Public | Case outcome established | 0 |
| Penley, William K. (missing 1958 found 1959) | Public | Documented recovery; OCR incomplete | 0 |
| The killing of Joseph Perry Jr. near Hammonton (1928) | Public | Unresolved homicide | 0 |
| Mary Phillips at Atsion (1880) | Public | Paraphrased, conflicting reports | 0 |
| The Pine Robbers | Public | Paraphrased historical account | 0 |
| The Quicklime Body (1935) | Public | Unresolved homicide | 0 |
| Joe Rego (1937) | Public | Sources compared and paraphrased | 0 |
| Reily, Charles - Medford Suicide 1909 | Public | Documented incident | 0 |
| Reily, William I (son suicide) | Public | Documented incident | 0 |
| Sidney Reso kidnapping (1992) | Public | Sources compared and paraphrased | 2 |
| South Jersey research resources | Public | Regional reference list | 3 |
| Henry D. Rider and the Hampton Park payroll attack (1916) | Public | Case outcome established | 0 |
| Roy Roberts | Public | Available sources summarized | 0 |
| The opening of the Royal Pine Hotel | Public | Contemporary source summarized | 0 |
| Galiano Sbraccia | Public | Available sources summarized | 0 |
| Scott, Allen Bodine (1954) | Public | Documented homicide case | 3 |
| Proposed Seaview County (1873) | Excluded | Uncorroborated title-only lead | 0 |
| Anthony J. Sharp | Public | Available sources summarized | 0 |
| Samuel Shinn (1908–1909) | Public | Documented accidental death | 1 |
| George Shotwell and Albert Foster (1907) | Public | Documented accidental poisoning | 1 |
| Shull, Harry H. (Captain) (1917) | Public | Unresolved death inquiry | 0 |
| Simons, Jacob - 1893 | Public | Biographical sketch | 3 |
| Slocum, Joseph (1959) | Public | Documented accidental death | 0 |
| Society Max, the bull who swam to Bayonne | Public | Clipping and oral history | 0 |
| Unidentified woman killed near Atsion (1892) | Public | Sources compared and paraphrased | 0 |
| Early Table of Contents | Excluded | Incomplete planning document | 0 |
| Everett Benjamin Thackara | Public | Available sources summarized | 1 |
| Theodore “Teddy” Pohlig’s arrest at Atsion Lake | Public | Contemporary report verified | 1 |
| Working Book Outline | Excluded | Planning document, not a historical source | 0 |
| The T.O.T.E. Pin Man (1928) | Public | Available sources summarized | 0 |
| Anna Towns | Public | Available sources summarized | 0 |
| Trenton-area sightings, 1878 | Public | Contemporary source summarized | 0 |
| The 1880 Tuckerton Railroad sale notice | Public | Contemporary source summarized | 0 |
| Unidentified 2013 | Excluded | Empty source page | 0 |
| 1948 Vincent Motorcycle Advertisement | Public | Classified advertisement summarized | 0 |
| Empty escaped-animal source page | Excluded | No historical content survives | 0 |
| James I. Wainwright murder (1884) | Public | Case outcome established | 1 |
| The man of the Passaic County mountains | Public | Contemporary source summarized | 0 |
| Ewing Township weather on April 20, 2015 | Public | Data summary | 0 |
| Whitesbog and the search for a better blueberry | Public | Documented history · Sources compared | 8 |
| Baggagemaster thrown from a moving train | Public | Contemporary source summarized | 0 |
| The Pine Lake Park crossing deaths | Public | Reports reconciled | 0 |
| The second Whiting station fire of 1897 | Public | Multiple reports compared | 0 |
| The two fish that stopped a freight train | Public | Contemporary source summarized | 0 |
| Francis E. Barnes and the stolen wool shipment | Public | Contemporary source summarized | 0 |
| Katie Woods | Public | Available sources summarized | 0 |